10 Reasons Baseball is Better Than Football

Unabashedly stolen from Brother Bill Bouie:
There's baseball, and then there are the minor sports. MLS, NBA, NFL, etc. Minor sports are all fine sports. They're just not baseball. They're not as interesting.
Baseball is perfect. Remember the first time you saw a major league diamond? Remember how it struck you?
You thought it was perfect, right? You were right then, and you're right now. Other sports come and go, but none of them can be as good as baseball.
Baseball isn't just better than football. It's better in dozens of ways. The game itself is better. The ballparks are better. The players are more skilled, the announcers more talented.
Opening Day is the best day of the year. The day after the World Series is the saddest.
Sometimes, baseball's off-season is more interesting than football's season. I felt this way even when I lived in places that didn't have knuckleheads running the NFL team.
It was a closer call in those places, but in the end, baseball always wins out. Anyway, on Super Bowl Sunday, let's run down some of the ways baseball is better than football:
1. Parity
MLB has more parity than the NFL. This wasn't always true. It is now. As the great Jayson Stark points out, since 2000, eight different MLB franchises have won the World Series. Meanwhile, seven NFL franchises have won the Super Bowl since 2000. Since 1970, 18 MLB franchises have won the World Series. Fifteen different NFL franchises have won championships in that span.
2. Skill level
Hitting a baseball is the hardest thing to do in sports. Throwing a baseball from 60 feet, 6 inches is the second-hardest thing. The NFL has some phenomenal athletes. None of them is as gifted as Albert Pujols, Lance Berkman and Roy Oswalt.
3. Diamonds
It's still one of God's greatest creations. It's perfection on every level. Next time you walk into Minute Maid Park, take a moment to appreciate it. From the perfectly trimmed grass to the raked infield dirt to the chalked lines, it's about the base place on earth to spend a few hours. No matter how bad a day I've had, stress flows from me when I see a big league diamond.
4. Ballparks
Baseball's worst parks are better than football's best. If you've ever spent an evening at Dodger Stadium, you'd understand. It's both tranquil and energizing if one place can be both. If you're really lucky, you'll someday stand on the right-field concourse at AT&T Park and admire the view of the bay, the odor of garlic fries, the majesty of the place.
5. Home runs
Ever see Will Clark launch one? Or Junior Griffey? Lance Berkman? The home run is the greatest thing in sports. It combines a high skill level with amazing power. That instant when the ball is soaring out of the park is indescribable. Have you ever enjoyed anything more than Jeff Kent's game-ending home run in Game 5 of the 2004 NLCS? Or Chris Burke's 18th-inning shot that ended a 2005 NLDS series against the Braves?
6. Season
A baseball season is perfect. As Bart Giamatti wrote, ''It breaks your heart. It is designed to break your heart. The game begins in the spring, when everything else begins again, and it blossoms in the summer, filling the afternoons and evenings, and then as soon as the chill rains come out, it stops and leaves you to face the fall alone. You count on it, rely on it to buffer the passage of time, to keep the memory of sunshine and high skies alive, and then just when the days are all twilight, when you need it most, it stops.''
7. Cheerleaders
Football has 'em. Baseball doesn't.
8. All-Star Game
Baseball's mid-summer classic is a celebration. Of great players. Of the game itself. Football has nothing even close. The Pro Bowl? Do they still have that?
9. MLBPA
Baseball players have a union that has represented its members better than any other on earth. Baseball is better for having a strong, independent union. Pity the poor retired NFL players that have trouble having their gruesome conditions cared for.
10. Labor peace
Thanks to Commissioner Selig, baseball has it. Football is headed for a shutdown in 2011.

6 comments:

  1. Wow!! Well written, Bill. Probably got your start writing in Freshman English from Fr. Prus - did you ever win that oil can trophy?
    I have been fortunate to see games in (ranked by my preference): Tiger Stadium (I bought two of those seats for my office), Wrigley Field, Fenway Park, Petco Park, Comerica Park, Phillies field, PNC, Jacobs Field. There are stories to tell of each park, but I loves them all. After reading Bill's essay I need to plan a California trip to see the Dodgers, Giants, and the A's Baseball is incredible!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Chuck,

    Great idea for a poll there! Other than Tiger Stadium (which I assume would come in first by a mile) what was your favorite stadium to visit in person? Guess we need a "pre-poll. "

    Guys, which stadiums, (beyond what Chuck listed) have you visited? I went to the old one in Toronto, old Comisky Park, the old donuts in Atlanta, Pittsburgh and Cinci, and The Ball park in Arlington (Texas.) (Maybe we can poll for minor league parks later in the season. My brother tells me Toldeo is great, I know Lakeland, Bradenton are nice, and a AA Ranger field here near us is very nice.)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I must be a well travelled as you guys. My ball park visits include Wrigley, Fenway and Camdem Yard (and of course, Tiger and Comerica)

    ReplyDelete
  4. I forgot about Fifth Third Field in Toledo. I love it. Games cost $9. A family of 4 can get a hot dog and a pop and get change for a $20. And you are right on top of the field of play.

    I also was at Camden Yards. Got Boog Powell's aoutograph there. many parks have an old time celeb sigining autographs. I got Manny Sangullien in Pittsburg, Luis Tiant in Boston and Greg Luzinski in Philly.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I've been to at least 40 major and minor league stadiums besides Tiger Stadium (which of course is the best and easily trumps Fenway and Wrigley):

    Cleveland Municipal Stadium (the mistake on the lake)
    Fenway
    Wrigley
    Yankee Stadium
    Shea Stadium
    Olympic Stadium (Montreal)
    Exhibition Stafium (Toronto)
    Busch Stadium St. Louis(not the brand new one)
    Veterans Stadium/Philly
    Three Rivers/Pitt
    Riverfront/Cinci
    Milwaukee County Stadium
    New Comiskey Park
    Joe Robbie/Pro Player/Florida Marlins
    Tropicana Dome in St. Pete
    Coors Field
    Camden Yards
    Memorial Stadium/Baltimore
    Astrodome
    Seattle Kingdome
    Kaufman Stadium/KC
    Ned Skeldon Stadium/Toldeo
    Cooper Stadium/Columbus OH
    Thurman Munson Stadium/Akron-Canton
    Rockwood Field/Birmingham, Ala.
    The new minor league park in Birmingham (Saw Air Jordan play there)
    San Antonio
    Cashman Field/Las Vegas
    Portland Maine
    Civic Stadium Portland Oregon
    Cheney Stadium/Tacoma WA
    Boise Idaho
    Billings Montana
    Meinen Field/Peoria Ill
    Robin ROberts Stadium/Springfield Ill
    Joker Marchant Stadium
    Chain of Lakes Stadium Winter Haven FL
    Baseball City Stadium, Haines City FL
    Greyson Stadium, Savannah GA
    Champion Stadium/Disney
    Roger Dean Stadium/Jupiter FL
    Doubleday Field/Cooperstown
    Anchorage, Alaska(Summer college league)
    Nat Bailey Stadium/Vancouver BC
    Thomas White Stadium/Port St Lucie FL
    Henley Field/Lakeland
    Colorado Springs
    Bush Stadium/Indianapolis
    Cardinal Stadium/Louisville KY

    Might've missed a few. You can see evidence here: http://picasaweb.google.com/Thomas.hagerty/Ballparks#

    After Tiger Stadium (greatest urinals in the history of the world)my top five MLB parks are/were:
    2. Milwaukee County Stadium
    3. Fenway (in the '70s before they added all those seats and turned it into a theme park)
    4. Wrigley Field
    5. Cleveland Municipal Stadium (it had a certain dank and decadent charm)

    Top five minor league stadiums:
    1. Joker Marchant Stadium
    2. Cheney Stadium/Tacoma WA
    3. Greyson Stadium/ Savannah GA
    4. Keefe Memorial Stadium/San Antonio
    5. Cooper Stadium/COlumbus OH

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tom,

    That is an impressive list. I can't compare, but I have been to a few.

    Fenway
    Tiger Stadium
    Comerica Park
    Wrigley
    Yankee Stadium
    Shea Stadium
    Olympic Stadium (Montreal)
    Exhibition Stafium (Toronto)
    Veterans Stadium/Philly
    Riverfront/Cinci
    Joe Robbie/Pro Player/Florida Marlins
    Tropicana Dome in St. Pete
    Coors Field
    Camden Yards
    Memorial Stadium/Baltimore
    Kaufman Stadium/KC
    Cooper Stadium/Columbus OH
    San Antonio
    Round Rock Stadium, Austin, TX
    Civic Stadium Portland Oregon
    Hagerstown, MD
    Frederick, MD
    Aberdeen, MD
    Salisbury, MD
    Bowie, MD
    Joker Marchant Stadium
    Chain of Lakes Stadium Winter Haven FL
    Baseball City Stadium, Haines City FL
    Greyson Stadium, Savannah GA
    Champion Stadium/Disney
    Dodger Stadium
    San Diego
    Kissimmee Stadium
    Henley Field/Lakeland
    Bank One, Phoenix
    Safeco, Seattle
    Vero Beach, Dodgertown
    Scottsdale Stadium
    Memphis Stadium
    Metrodome, Minneapolis
    Oakland Alameda
    Bush Stadium/Indianapolis
    Cardinal Stadium/Louisville KY

    ReplyDelete